In today’s digital age, the availability of countless guitar learning resources—YouTube videos, online courses, books, and forums—may seem like a blessing. However, while access to many learning sources is beneficial in some fields, when it comes to mastering an instrument like the guitar, too much information from different sources can actually slow progress, confuse you, and make learning more frustrating than it needs to be.
Why Learning from Too Many Sources is a Problem
There is more than one effective way to teach core concepts such as music theory, picking technique, muting, chords, strumming, and other fundamental skills. However, explanations from different teachers or sources often use different terminologies, emphasize different techniques, and may even seem contradictory if you don’t yet have a solid foundation in one method.
Example: Explaining the Lydian Mode
- Teacher One: “You raise the fourth note of the major scale by a half step.”
- Teacher Two: “Start any major scale on the fourth note, and you have the Lydian scale.”
Both explanations are technically correct, but if you attempt to learn both approaches at the same time without fully grasping either one, they might appear to conflict with each other. This can result in frustration and confusion, hindering your ability to make meaningful progress. Until you have practiced with one method long enough to internalize it, blending explanations can create unnecessary obstacles to understanding.
The Best Way to Learn Guitar Effectively
Instead of bouncing between various teachers or learning sources, the most effective way to learn is to commit to a single reputable source first.
- Choose a single instructor that resonates with you and stick with their approach.
- Learn their methods thoroughly, practicing consistently and trusting their process.
- Avoid the temptation to compare different approaches, as this can lead to unnecessary doubt and second-guessing.
Once you have established a solid foundation and can confidently apply what you’ve learned, you will be in a significantly better position. By that point, you’ll possess enough knowledge to critically evaluate various approaches without feeling overwhelmed or confused.
The Dangers of Mixing Too Many Sources Too Soon
1. You Develop Bad Habits
If you constantly switch between different methods, you might end up with an inconsistent playing technique. One teacher may emphasize a specific way of muting excess string noise, while another recommends something entirely different. Both approaches may work with enough consistent practice, but frequently switching before mastering one method will hinder your ability to develop the muscle memory and good technique needed to play with ease.
2. You Waste Time and Lose Confidence
When you keep trying different approaches without fully committing to one, progress becomes slow and frustrating. This can lead to self-doubt, making you feel like you’re not improving or that the guitar is harder than it actually is. Many learners quit simply because they feel stuck in an endless cycle of trying to reconcile different instructions.
3. Not All Sources Are Reliable
While the internet is flooded with guitar resources, it’s crucial to recognize that not all of them are created equal. Many instructors, lacking formal training, offer advice that may not only be ineffective but can also instill bad habits that are hard to break down the line. Without a solid foundation, beginners struggle to discern the difference between trustworthy guidance and unreliable information, which can sabotage their progress. Investing in quality instruction at the outset sets the stage for a more successful and enjoyable guitar journey. Don’t settle for mediocrity; choose your resources wisely to ensure your growth as a musician!
The Value of Learning from a Single, Experienced Teacher
Some students assume that guitar teachers discourage learning from multiple sources just to keep students committed to their lessons. But even if every guitar teacher in the world offered free lessons, this problem would still exist.
As the saying goes, “If you think hiring a professional is expensive, try hiring an amateur.” Learning from a teacher who understands how to communicate concepts effectively saves you from the struggle of piecing together scattered advice from unreliable sources.
If you’re learning from an experienced, well-trained teacher, trust their process. Instead of seeking conflicting explanations elsewhere, ask them your questions. A good teacher will be happy to clarify concepts for you, whether in lessons or through email.
us leo.
A Structured Approach is Key
To become a great guitarist, you don’t need to know everything at once—you need to know the right things at the right time. That’s why structured learning is so important. Rather than overwhelming yourself with a patchwork of disconnected ideas, follow a logical progression that allows you to develop your skills systematically.
Conclusion
While having access to multiple learning sources can be an advantage, trying to absorb too much too soon can slow you down, create confusion, and lead to frustration. The best way to learn guitar is to find a reputable teacher and stick with them. By staying focused, patient, and committed to a single learning method at a time, you will progress more efficiently and confidently, ultimately becoming a better guitarist in the long run.
About The Author
Brian Fish is a professional guitarist who has been dedicated to helping other guitar players in Northeast Ohio pursue their musical dreams since 1994. He’s passionate about guiding others on their musical journey! He is the Guitar Playing Transformation Specialist, instructor, mentor, trainer, and coach at Guitar Lessons Geauga.
Brian has also assisted people from around the globe in developing a solid sense of timing and enhancing their creativity through the fantastic rhythm course, “Ultimate Rhythm Mastery,” available at MusicTheoryForGuitar.com.
If you live in Geauga County / North East Ohio, Guitar Lessons Geauga can help you become the player you’ve always wanted to be.
